Nerd Fight: Best Doctor Who Companion – Malice-Corp Weekly Poll

  1. Nerd Fight: The Best Doctor Companion of All Time

Hello all you Geek Enthusiasts and Nerd Aficionados!

We are back with another poll for this week. Last week saw the fight for the best Tarantino Flick of all time. You can see the results of last weeks poll posted by our amazing Mest5150. On each week’s podcast the Malice Corp crew will choose who they want to put in the ring. This weeks order was determined by whose pick got the most votes in last weeks poll. This week we are delving into the wonderful and vast world of Doctor Who and pitting companion against companion. So let the battle commence, and here is you contestants for the week ahead.

Rose Tyler-

  • Played by the beautiful Billie Piper, She is the companion that kicks off the revival. Companion to both Doctors 9 and 10, she traveled with the Doctor until She became stranded in a parallel universe. She makes a return and helps 10 end the Dalek threat to the universe. She is rewarded by getting to live out her life with the human incarnation of the 10th Doctor.


Billie Piper, Rose Tyler

Susan Foreman

  • Played by Carol Ann Ford, Susan is representing Classic Who on this weeks Whovian poll. Susan was the assumed name of a Time Lady who was the original companion. She was granddaughter of the doctor. She traveled with the first and fifth incarnations of the doctor. The Tenth Doctor once said that he had left Susan on a future Earth with a freedom fighter with whom she had fallen in love

Susan, Carol Ann Ford


Amy Pond-

  • Played by Karen Gillan, Amy was also referred to as  The Girl who Waited. Amelia Pond was the first companion of the Doctor in his Eleventh incarnation. Amy was the girlfriend and later wife of Rory Williams, who also traveled with the Doctor. She was also the mother of Melody Pond, who later became known as River Song. She was lost to the Doctor when she allowed a weeping angel to send her back in time to be reunited with her husband Rory. Karen Gillan, Amy Pond


Donna Noble-

  • Portrayed by Catherine Tate, she is a companion of the Tenth Doctor. Despite her humble beginnings, she was described by both Rose and the Tenth Doctor as being the most important woman in all of creation. This credit was because she saved the whole of reality from the Daleks and Davros.  To survive the side effects of her transformation into the “Doctor-Donna”, the doctor was forced to wipe her memories. She was sadly returned to her family with no memories of the adventures she and the doctor had shared, which is truly the most tragic fate of all the companions. Donna Noble, Catherine Tate


Captain Jack Harkness-

  • Played by John Barrowman, he was a Time Agent and con man from the 51st Century who became an associate and companion of the Ninth and Tenth Doctors. He was killed by a Dalek and revived by Rose Tyler as the Bad Wolf and accidentally transformed into a man who cannot die. He eventually goes on to form Torchwood, an agency dedicated to eliminating alien threats on Earth. Jack Harkness, John Barrowman


River Song-

  • Played by Alex Kingston, she was born Melody Pond, and known as a Child of the Tardis. She was also the wife of the doctor, specifically his eleventh incarnation. She was a human with Time lord DNA. This occurred when conceived by her parents, Amy and Rory Williams, aboard the TARDIS as it traveled through the Time Vortex. She also had some Time Lord abilities like regeneration, and one of the few people to know the doctors true name. She died saving the Tenth Doctor and all the people trapped from the Library of the Vashta Nerada. The Tenth Doctor was able to save and upload her consciousness into the library’s mainframe to survive. River Song, Alex Kingston

Time to vote

There you have it folks, those are this week’s combatants. So, get your whovian hats on and get ready to debate. Vote for your Companion of choice. Also, if you want to see why we chose who we did then make sure to listen to this week’s podcast. You can find it either at or YouTube. Heck, while your there you can even subscribe and that way you’ll know when our next podcast is airing.

Finally, if you would like further insights into the characters, click on their name  and it will take you to their respective wiki pages. Voting goes until April 14, 11:59:59 PM PST. So, don’t dilly dally. Get your vote in and help give someone on the podcast bragging rights for this week.

[poll id=”7″]

SuperwhovianFreak Out

13 thoughts on “Nerd Fight: Best Doctor Who Companion – Malice-Corp Weekly Poll

  • April 9, 2017 at 4:02 pm

    I voted for #CaptJackHarkness because, leading Torchwood, he continues to protect Earth and no other companion can claim that.

    • April 11, 2017 at 12:01 pm

      Ummmmm Martha Jones? Plus Mickey…

    • April 12, 2017 at 10:35 pm

      sarah jane smith can, rose and mickey can in the other dimension, we dont know what susan’s doing, martha is with mickey,there are many versions of clara out there despite the true one traveling with lady me, just saying, i dont mean offense by this i just feel i should point out jack isnt the only one

  • April 11, 2017 at 12:02 pm

    But I voted for Captain Jack Harkness

  • April 11, 2017 at 7:44 pm

    Well. Donna was not only the “most important woman in the whole wide universe”, but the ONLY companion with whom Who seemed like he could completely be himself with. That being said, much love to Mister Rory Pond; who else looked after EVERYONE the way Rory did?

  • April 12, 2017 at 10:31 pm

    i feel wrong having to choose, jacks my favorite male companion and donna and amy tie for 1rst, plus rose is third river is in second, i havent gotten to see susan so i cant vote her fairly

    • Jack Malice
      April 12, 2017 at 10:36 pm

      Well it is a Nerd Fight x2 for you then! Both external and internal! Thanks for coming out and joining us in the vote. We appreciate all the attention this poll has received! Malice-Corp hopes everyone will return for next weeks poll as well!

    • Jack Malice
      April 26, 2017 at 12:04 pm

      Hello Deb
      #NerdFights are 1 week long polls that run on the site. This on is about 2 weeks old. Sorry that you missed it. This weeks is all about Buffy!
      Or you can find the current #NerdFight on the home page near the bottom!

      Sorry again but thank you for your interest! If you have ideas for #NerdFight polls or content you can always use the contact us form or tweet at your favorite Malice Corp contributor. They are always listening.


      To just name a few


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *